Crimbo Relief Rally 2008
Route Card 5 Answers
Crimbo Relief Rally 2008 Route Cards & Solutions
Alternative correct answers on separate lines.
Correct answers in black. Incorrect answers in red.
 
  Time Taken  
No. Name Class Score Days Hours Mins Secs Ans 1 Ans 2 Ans 3 Ans 4 Ans 5 Ans 6 Ans 7 Ans 8 Ans 9 Ans 10 Comment
 Correct Answer      YYW
YWY
WYY
yyw
ywy
wyy
YYw
Y,W,Y
6
RRW
RWR
WRR
rrw
rwr
wrr
www
WWW
RRWW
RWRW
RWWR
WRRW
WRWR
WWRR
rrww
rwrw
rwwr
wrrw
wrwr
wwrr
W,R,R
3
5
6
7
8786
4
5
3
 
2Mike BurrowsX3012949 7983 5 8582 3 5 4 9086 5 4 3 
3Ian CanavanX5015316 YWY 5 WRR 2 5 5 WWW 6 5 3 I would have been happier to see a red 'pa' instead of a red 'p' on line two, part one. Also should there not have been a yellow 'E' after the yellow '2'? Not sure what the green zigzags were either? Also, there is a ‘.’ on the map just before the final red ‘C’, it’s a tiny circle instead of a spot, which OS sometimes use instead of a spot when very close to a boundary line. Picky, I know!
13Glynn HaywardX901045 yyy 6 wrr 3 5 7 8786 4 5 3  RC5)2 Horizontal & 3 Vertical RC8)3 H & 1 V RC10)ChT in 8783 measures just over 200m from Orange. otherwise answer is 4
14Clive HodgsonX2005937 YYW 5 YYW 2 5 Replace with Answer 6 Replace with Answer 7 Replace with Answer 8 Replace with Answer 9 Replace with Answer 10 
17Richard ScottX7753630 YYW 4 RRW 3 5 4 8786 4 7 3 
18Phil RobbinsX7025624 YYW 6 RRW 3 5 5 8768 4 6 3 
19David KilleenX9031743 YWY 6 WRR 3 5 6 8786 4 6 3 In part one is there a yellow E missing between a yellpw 2 and a red E? In part 2 I could not find the G in PC?G.
21Pip SeckerX000489 8083 3 8181 4 Replace with Answer 5 Replace with Answer 6 Replace with Answer 7 Replace with Answer 8 Replace with Answer 9 Replace with Answer 10 
22Chris BeanX8015418 YWY 6 WRR 3 5 4 8786 4 7 3  For #3, I couldn't determine if the road continued through "Head of Muir", in which case the answer would be WWRR.
23Ron BatemanX50205919 YYY 5 YYY 2 5 6 8786 4 6 3 
24Alan LargeX60192622 8085 6 8181 3 5 4 8786 4 6 3 
25Gillian GoodlassX9032646 YWY 6 WRR 3 4 6 8786 4 5 3 
27Keith CunninghamX6023959 yyw 5 wrr 8181 5 4 8786 4 6 3 1st church on B905 out of Stenhousemuir does not touch the road so counted the 2 churches with towers off the main road as per instruction ++++
28Dee Rampling LeeX400477 YWY 4 WRR 3 4 5 8786 8 6 4  WELL what can I say. Had to guess what you were meaning even in the first section. Will justify my first set of answers as not at all certain of second set! Q1 801836 Q2 82108485, 80208585, 80408340, 83558565 Q3 81258130 as I saw no way round from 2 on a Yellow to E on the Red without using the white which was not asked for? Q4 80558540, 81458270, 84258510 Q5 2 GL84 Eastings and Northings so therefore 80308400, 84008285, 84008535, 84008620
29Phillip KingX8013842 YWY 6 WRR 3 5 5 8786 6 5 3  included the first W>Y because instructions had started
30Alex HoultX14204159 YY 4 RRR 2 4 4 8886 5 3 3 Mostly guessed. I have a route but it is probably not the one you were thinking of.
31Alan WhitneyX22961957 Replace with Answer 1 5 Replace with Answer 3 4 9 6 Replace with Answer 7 7 Replace with Answer 9 3 
32Robert OwenX100143621 YYW 6 WRR 3 5 6 8786 4 5 3 General:(it's a long list!!): Part1: 1) Missing command after yellow 2? 2) Missing 'red a' before or after 'red p'? Part2: 3) Have taken route via orange aftre 1st R on A88 to be shortest solution. This gives one more Y>W than the alternative route using the red/white route to Bensfield. 4) In block e m n e I have used orange as white is possibly not a through road. Doesn't affect any answers though as I've used the R beforehand. 5) To fulfill block B + L a I have used the route approaching L from the north (otherwise a L?). Using the route south of Larbert would add 2 more GL85's. 6) Is block P C? G . ok? The G seems a bit dodgy! 7) I have taken the white between blocks r e r r and + E + E (just south of r r) as being the shortest route.
33Steve TurnbullX10011924 YWY 6 WRR 3 5 6 8786 4 5 3  It really does not help when the route is on areas you know very well!!!
34David KeetleyX4003114 yyy 6 wrr 3 5 Replace with Answer 6 Replace with Answer 7 Replace with Answer 8 Replace with Answer 9 Replace with Answer 10 
35Josie GreenawayX7021224 YYY 6 WRR 3 5 5 8786 4 7 3 
36Chris TowersX51143750 YYW 7 RRWW 2 3 5 8786 4 6 3 
38Brian AmblerX0002043 Replace with Answer 1 Replace with Answer 2 Replace with Answer 3 Replace with Answer 4 Replace with Answer 5 Replace with Answer 6 Replace with Answer 7 Replace with Answer 8 Replace with Answer 9 Replace with Answer 10 
41David SmoleyX804184 YYW 6 RRW 3 5 7 8786 4 6 4 
42Mike BissX10041415 YWY 6 WRR 3 5 6 8786 4 5 3 Part 1 seems to be missing a yellow E immediately after the yellow 2. Part 2. Can't seem to find a single G to go through on the P C? G . part in 9185 area.
43Francis TindallX10052846 YYW 6 RRW 3 5 6 8786 4 5 3 
44Sara RileyX502626 YYY 4 WRR 3 5 4 8786 4 6 2 Junction answer to 3 taken as staggered and not crossroads. If crossroads then WRRW.
45Geoff MastermanX802448 YYw 6 WRR 3 5 4 8786 4 6 3 
46Alan CrabtreeX9035529 YWY 6 WRR 3 5 4 8786 4 5 3  I think the one I've dropped here may be because of the marginal decision over the ChT at GR876831. I measured this one at several different magnifications of the PDF map, and the result varies between 205 and 208 metres. I therefore did not count it, but if you decided that it is 200 metres then my answer would be 4. ********************* Harking back to previously submitted Routecards, don't you feel a pr** when you've had a rant about something and then realise that you got something wrong yourself! I now see that in Routecards 3,4 and 6 I stupidly answered the J-x questions with the GS number instead of the road colours!! This has cost me potentially 5 points, assuming I had the right junctions, and was done despite doing it correctly in RC2! For the record, my answers to the relevant rc's should have been:- RC3, rc5 - YOO RC3, rc7 - WWW RC5, rc6 - YWY (which i see as marginally more west than the YYY just south of it) RC6, rc3 - YYY RC6, rc8 - WWW ++++++++++++++ Can anybody give me the map reference of a suitable hole to dig myself into?
64Henry CarrX6032352 YYW 7 WRR 3 5 5 8796 4 6 3 
65Brian JohnsonX74234437 8083 7 8181 3 5 6 8786 4 5 3 
67Martin MooreX301103 8083 5 8181 2 5 4 8786 4 6 2 Not really sure what was required with this section!!
70Arwel JonesX503286 YWY 5 RWR 2 5 7 8786 3 6 4 
75Thomas CampbellX6021255 YYY 6 WRR 3 5 4 8786 2 3 3 
77Jon LunnX8053815 Y,W,Y 6 W,R,R 3 5 7 8786 3 7 3 
80Anthony DaviesX10013538 YWY 6 WRR 3 5 7 8786 4 5 3 rc6
81Tim HareX9022723 YWY 6 WRR 3 4 6 8786 4 5 3 
82Andrew KellittX80202256 YYY 6 WRWR 3 4 6 8786 4 5 3 
83Harry GeorgeX511235755 8083 6 8081 3 5 5 8786 4 6 2 Regarding RC10, a third ChT may be within 200m of route in grid square 8783 but difficult to measure precisely the distance so please take my alternative answer of RC10 = 3.
84Mick WicksX84133754 YYWW 6 WRR 3 5 5 8786 4 5 3 Can't find G between C? & . which I presume is SH4 in 9184. The white loop in 9185 has 3 No. G's but if this was the intended route then Route Check 6 would be 6
85Kevin NugentX000297 Replace with Answer 1 Replace with Answer 2 Replace with Answer 3 Replace with Answer 4 Replace with Answer 5 Replace with Answer 6 Replace with Answer 7 Replace with Answer 8 Replace with Answer 9 Replace with Answer 10 
86Iain TullieX9011541 YYY 6 RRW 3 5 6 8786 4 5 3 RC3 - would be RRWW if white through 'H' of 'Head' in 8181 is considered to 'go'. RC10 - considered ChT in 8783 just over 200m away, very close, so could be 4 instead of 3.
88Tony FieldX2783048 YY 4 RRW 2 5      
89Keith PettittX204012 wyy 4 RRR 2 2 3 8786 2 7 2 More guesses with each card
91Nigel ParishX6014924 8083 6 8181 2 5 5 8786 4 5 3 
99Paul TaylorX804364 ywy 6 wrr 3 4 6 8786 3 5 3 
107Peter JohnstoneX6023242 WWW 7 YYY 3 5 5 8786 4 5 3 
108John ElkinX8015243 YYW 6 RRW 3 5 6 8785 4 4 3 
111Peter RobertsonX9012045 yyw 6 rrw 3 5 6 8786 5 5 3  RC3) May br rrww- the possible white is concealed by the 'H' RC8) Counted 5 to ensure 'L' before 'a' in GS8582 RC9) Counted Orange R in GS 8883 since possible white obscured by the 'e'
113Steve BarberX10014646 YYW 6 WWW 3 5 6 8786 4 5 3 
121Jonathan ForrestX0001315 Replace with Answer 1 Replace with Answer 2 Replace with Answer 3 Replace with Answer 4 Replace with Answer 5 Replace with Answer 6 Replace with Answer 7 Replace with Answer 8 Replace with Answer 9 Replace with Answer 10 
122Hannah CessfordX6015237 YYW 6 WWRR 2 3 5 8786 6 5 3 
132Jonathan SargeantX000137 Replace with Answer 1 Replace with Answer 2 Replace with Answer 3 Replace with Answer 4 Replace with Answer 5 Replace with Answer 6 Replace with Answer 7 Replace with Answer 8 Replace with Answer 9 Replace with Answer 10 
133Ken LarkingX101172819 YWY 6 WRR 3 5 6 8786 4 5 3 Route check 9: 2 roundabouts are used twice. Number of DIFFERENT roundabouts used = 5. Number of times route VISITS a roundabout = 7. Have answered 5 because question specifically askes for number of DIFFERENT roundabouts visited. Route Instructions Part 1: Should not the yellow digit '2' be followed by a yellow capital 'E'??
135David BellX1002205 YWY 6 WRR 3 5 6 8786 4 5 3 Part 1 - is there a missing instruction (yellow E) between yellow 2 (inst 30) and red E (inst 31)? Part 2 - can't find a G between C? and . (block 7?) - assumed the C? referred to PC and the . is SH4 - there are 3 Gates on the white loop but the C is nowhere near touching the yellow so I guess I've missed something vital! Assume that you don't class the water crossing in GS 8880 as a couple of Bridges. Assume the road junction in GS 8581 is NOT a roundabout.
137David LeavyX502120 WYY 5 WRR 2 3 4 8786 1 5 3 
138George CowlingX04105340 ryw 7 wwww 2 8 5 8982 5 3 4