Panglossian Rally 2008
Route Card 3 Answers
Panglossian Rally 2008 Route Cards & Solutions
Alternative correct answers on separate lines.
Correct answers in black. Incorrect answers in red.
 
  Time Taken  
No. Name Class Score Days Hours Mins Secs Ans 1 Ans 2 Ans 3 Ans 4 Ans 5 Ans 6 Ans 7 Ans 8 Ans 9 Ans 10 Comment
 Correct Answer      3
4
2
Y
YES
yes
Yes
N
NO
no
No
n
5392
1
6
51
5691
112
6
 
104Peter BoothE400322 3 1 Y 5392 1      
106Peter HarbordE5004116 3 2 Y 5392 1      
108Philip RobbinsM10021025 3 2 N 5392 1 6 51 5691 112 6 The answer to RC3 is dependant on wether you consider the 2 whites in GS5390 merge with ref to regulation 20. When blown up on pdf map my interpretation is that they don't so consequently the route just takes the normal route through grid square ie shortest route thus making the "LWR" irrelevent unless of course it was just a way of encouraging mistakes.If these whites do go then the answer should be Y.
110Brian JohnsonM1046229 3 2 Y 5392 1 6 51 5691 112 6 
111Clive HodgsonE5005041 3 2 Y 5392 1      
112James NewbouldE4001514 3 0 no 5392 1      
113Andrew FishN4003835 2 2 N 5392 1      
115Geoff MastermanE4002936 3 0 Y 5392 1      
119Martin MooreE5002250 3 2 Y 5392 1      
122Steve TurnbullE5001554 3 2 Y 5392 1      
126Steve BarberM10012915 3 2 Y 5392 1 6 51 5691 112 6 RC1. Alternative answer 4 if Y>W at 510893.
129Gill SweetmanE4021816 2 2 Y 5392 1      
131Shane GlynnM9704636 3 2 N 5392 1 5 51 5691 112 6 
148Gillian GoodlassM10025513 3 2 Y 5392 1 6 51 5691 112 6 
150Gavin RogersM10003513 4 2 Y 5392 1 6 51 5691 112 6 RC1 - Using W at 509.5 892 for shortest route and treating junction under "88" as Y>W and not as R>W otherwise RC1 would be 3 and RC2 would be 3
151Catherine BuckE4005329 3 1 N 5392 1      
154Keith CramN000955 Replace with Answer 1 Replace with Answer 2 Replace with Answer 3 Replace with Answer 4 Replace with Answer 5      
156Robert OwenM10024514 4 2 Y 5392 1 6 51 5691 112 6 Q1: White in GS5089 considered through road and shortest route, thus making 4 Y>W's. (Cross GL51 at 8928) Also have assumed Y to be continuous under GC in Wootton!
159Mark AspinwallE5002134 4 2 Y 5392 1      
163Keith KingE5002422 3 2 Y 5392 1      
165Mike BurrowsM8301521 2 2 Y 5392 1 5 51 5691 112 6 
166Peter SmithM102075644 4 2 Y 5392 1 6 51 5691 112 6 
169Mike HopperE000027 Replace with Answer 1 Replace with Answer 2 Replace with Answer 3 Replace with Answer 4 Replace with Answer 5      
171Richard LomaxN4001741 2 2 N 5392 1      
173Peter RobertsonM9011059 3 1 Y 5392 1 6 51 5691 112 6 RC1 Query LWR in GS 5390 since no visible join in the 2 whites, but I have assumed you think there is,hence 3, and hence "Lodge" RC3 is a Y. Cannot also count the short urban whites in GS5089(on GL51).
179Brian AmblerN4011822 2 2 Y 5392 1      
181Janet RobbinsN500408 3 2 No 5392 1      
183George CowlingE2013353 2 3 yes 5492 1      
189Peter DaviesE4002526 2 2 Y 5392 1      
190Glynn HaywardM1001925 3 2 Y 5392 1 6 51 5691 112 6 
193Brian BanksM9045511 3 2 Y 5391 1 6 51 5691 112 6 
196Alan LargeE5003620 3 2 Y 5392 1      
198Bernie McEneanyE5005113 3 2 Y 5392 1      
201Mark DunkerleyN5001536 4 2 n 5392 1      
205Tim HassallE3004313 2 1 N 5392 1      RC1 and RC2 Junction in 5088 app NE dep SW judged as being yellow to white without going onto red - or maybe its me on the wrong road....
209Phillip KingE5004145 4 2 Y 5392 1      
211Iain TullieM10003554 4 2 Y 5392 1 6 51 5691 112 6 
214Colin RichardsonN3002311 2 1 N 5392 1      3)Could not go nam as i could not access white loop from the white from the north as there is no break in the line between the two whites? near "Lodge"
216Sara RileyE401228 6 2 Y 5392 1      
218Sally BlakeN101646 5 1 yes 5292 0      
233Dee Rampling LeeE500476 4 2 Y 5392 1      Wow! I was really doubting myself on this one as there seemed to be a variety of answers due to the comments I made. So what happened with the roads running pararell?
234Richard LakingN2003528 4 1 5392 Y 1      
235Alan CrabtreeM10023525 4 2 Y 5392 1 6 51 5691 112 6  I was not happy about using the White south from GS5391 to GS5390, as I was not convinced there was a join to the W-Y loop in GS5390, but LWR is specified, and the only other way to leave GS5390 via the W border is by following the Y straight through the NW corner of the square, which is not a "LWR". Also, the Longest Way Round in GS5389 from S to E (12LWR) would exit the GS on the W at 540891, but this would lead to GS5490, and the subsequent instructions would not be possible. Other than these two observations I can't see anything contentious about the route, so have no idea where I could have dropped 2 points!
236Kevin NugentN4002235 3 1 Y 5392 1      
241Pip SeckerE501152 4 2 Y 5392 1      
242David KilleenM900526 2 2 N 5392 1 6 51 5691 112 6 Did not use the LWR in 5390 as the whites do not connect and so as not to use the same section of road more than once I took the longest route which was also the shortest route - So also the word "lodge" was not approached
243Julian ChallisN5001631 3 2 Y 5392 1      
247David KeetleyE401829 4 1 Y 5392 1      
251Sasha HeriotN3003510 3 1 1 5392 1      
254Steve BubbE5002439 3 2 N 5392 1      
264Ian CanavanM101194441 4 2 Y 5392 1 6 51 5691 112 6 Assumes white goes at 519893?
265Chris BeanN5003145 4 2 Y 5392 1      
268Jonathan ForrestN400226 0 2 N 5392 1      
270Norman NicolsonN5003211 4 2 Y 5392 1      
272Nigel ParishE4003218 2 2 N 5392 1      
275Francis TindallM9093510 4 1 Y 5392 1 6 51 5691 112 6 
279Jasmin CongreveN5003624 3 2 N 5392 1      
283David SmoleyE5001016 3 2 Y 5392 1      
284Jo WhiteN4003548 2 2 Y 5392 1      
287Ron BatemanN5303541 4 2 Y 5392 1      
290David MiddleditchM92303832 3 2 N 5392 1 5 51 5691 112 6 
292Rob LunnN30204641 2 0 no 5392 1      not sure what LWR was supposed to mean